Disproportionate Burden Assessment

Introduction and background

Health Education and Improvement Wales (HEIW) is the statutory education and strategic workforce organisation for NHS Wales.

As a Special Health Authority with an all-Wales remit, we work with partners across health, social care, education and government to strengthen the workforce that underpins care in NHS Wales.

As the national body for workforce planning, education, training and leadership, we play a system wide role in helping NHS Wales respond to current and future workforce needs.

Our website is one way that we communicate information about our services to stakeholders, universities, the public, and NHS Wales health boards. 

HEIW is committed to making our website accessible as set out in the Public Sector Bodies (Websites and Mobile Applications) (No. 2) Accessibility Regulations 2018. This includes making our websites and mobile apps accessible and publishing an accessibility statement.

Public bodies must comply with version 2.2 of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) AA requirements at levels A and AA.

These regulations state that when it is not feasible for a public sector body to meet one of these accessibility requirements, for example because it is difficult to fix or too expensive, they must provide a disproportionate burden assessment.

We have prepared this disproportionate burden assessment to describe why we are not able to offer fully accessible versions of some content on the site, specifically PDF documents.
 

Non-compliance with accessibility regulations

Non-accessible PDFs

The HEIW website hosts a large number of PDFs that do not meet WCAG 2.2 accessibility guidelines. There are 2,771 in total as of October 2026, which have been created by multiple authors over several years. They are primarily technical or corporate, and are mostly related to:

  • Board or committee papers
  • Data standards
  • Performance reports which may contain complex reporting/statistical data
  • Policies and procedures produced since September 2018
  • Publications linked from our Freedom of Information pages – including disclosure logs
  • Publications which may have been professionally produced since September 2018 which would have to be fixed by a third party

Some of the issues identified in the PDFs include:

  • A lack of alt text on images and diagrams
  • Poor colour contrast
  • Incorrect tagging structure for elements like headings, tables and lists
     

Assessment of cost and benefits

We believe that the total time and cost of fixing all these PDF documents to meet accessibility standards represents a disproportionate burden.

We estimate it would take up to three hours (for smaller documents) and up to 30 hours (for larger documents) to fix in accordance with the WCAG 2.2 accessibility requirements. This is because a significant number of the documents are particularly long and complex, like board and committee papers. For example, in 2025, the average length of our board papers was 303 pages per document. 

To fix all 2,771 PDFs on the website, it could take between 1,108 and 11,084 working days in total (based on one member of staff and a typical HEIW working day of 7.5 hours). This would take team resource away from other high-priority work.
 

Impact on users

We know that inaccessible PDF documents can be difficult to read and understand. We offer alternative support to users who have additional access needs. To request an accessible PDF, large print, easy read, audio recording or braille, contact: heiw.digital@wales.nhs.uk. We will consider your request and get back to you in 10 working days. 

Pages that host PDFs see a much lower level of traffic, which means the number of people who would benefit from making the accessibility fixes is smaller. 

For example, the number of unique users to pages that house board paper PDFs accounts for 0.33% of all website users:

  • Total website: 451,026 unique users
  • Board meeting pages: 1,509 unique users

(Based on 12 months of Google Analytics data captured from 1 April 2025 - 31 March 2026).

 

What we're doing to address these accessibility issues

We’re committed to improving accessibility. We want all users to be able to navigate and understand our content. 

The Communications team is responsible for publishing most of the organisational and service-led information on the website. As part of our commitment to reducing the number of inaccessible PDFs on the website we will only upload PDFs that have been deemed essential for business or reporting purposes. These PDFS will adhere to the WCAG 2.2 accessibility requirements, with the exception for board and committee papers.

 

Board and committee papers

The HEIW Corporate Governance team currently uses software called AdminControl to create and manage the board and committee papers that are published on the website. This software does not meet several WCAG 2.2 compliance criteria, for example, the documents it produces have:

  • incorrect reading order
  • no option to set the meta title 
  • no option to set the language of a document

We are improving the accessibility of the templates that we submit to AdminControl, including reducing the number of unnecessary tables and setting the correct colour contrast. We are also providing further guidance to staff about accessibility checking tools and their responsibilities as document publishers.

We are reviewing our long-term use of AdminControl due to its accessibility issues.
 

How to request content in an accessible format

We offer alternative support to users who have additional access needs. To request an accessible PDF, large print, easy read, audio recording or braille, contact heiw.digital@wales.nhs.uk. We will consider your request and get back to you in 10 working days. 

This assessment was prepared in October 2026. It will be updated to reflect further progress in October 2027.